Commentary

Commonwealth Court Imposes its Own Interpretation Over an Arbitrator’s Interpretation

One of the first things they teach you in an arbitration class is that the Court may not overturn an arbitration award merely because it disagrees with the arbitrator’s reasoning. But, the Court did just that in School District of Philadelphia v. Philadelphia Federation of Teachers, Local 3. On July…

Read More

Pa. Supreme Court Limits the Cost of Obtaining Medical Records – A Victory for the Consumer

On June 16th, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court favored litigants with limited funds over companies trying to make a profit reproducing records, ruling that medical providers and companies that provide medical records to the public may only charge the actual and reasonable expenses of reproducing the records, provided those expenses do…

Read More

Two New Workers’ Compensation Decisions Highlight the Fragility of Credibility Findings

In the last week, two Commonwealth Court opinions highlight the difference between the Court’s stated view – that it won’t overturn credibility findings supported in the record – and the reality that Courts do it all the time when they desire a specific result. One of the cases, Arvilla Oilfield…

Read More

U.S. Supreme Court & Florida Supreme Court Decisions May Have Significant Impact on Pennsylvania Civil Litigation & Damages

Two recent decisions by the U.S. Supreme Court and the Florida Supreme Court may have a significant impact on Pennsylvania cases. In Daimler AG v. Bauman, No 11-965 (January 14, 2014), the U.S. Supreme Court stepped into the murky waters of jurisdiction, with a decision that will almost certainly limit…

Read More

Voter ID Decision – A Public Opinion Not Available to the Public?

Today, Commonwealth Court Judge Robert Simpson issued his long-awaited decision concerning Pennsylvania's controversial legislation requiring voters to show identification before being able to vote. Specifically, Judge Simpson preliminarily enjoined the Commonwealth (and election officials) from requiring voters to show ID prior to being permitted to vote. The decision, in Applewhite…

Read More